democratizing GIS
Home   Store   Free GIS   Education   Free Shapefiles   Census   Weather   Energy   Climate Change   News   Maps   TOPO   Aerial   GPS   Learn GIS

DOWNLOAD SHAPEFILES: Canada FSA Postal - Zip Code - U.S. Waterbodies & Wetlands - Geographic Names - School Districts - Indian Federal Lands
Zip Code/Demographics - U.S. Streams, Rivers & Waterways - Tornadoes - Nuclear Facilities - Dams & Risk - 2013 Toxic Release Inventory TRI

FREE MAPCRUZIN UPDATES
Enter your e-mail



GIS Shapefile Store - for Beginners & Experienced GIS Users Alike. Geographic Names Information System, Nuclear Facilities, Zip Code Boundaries, School Districts, Indian & Federal Lands, Climate Change, Tornadoes, Dams - Create digital GIS maps in minutes.

Toxic Release Inventory TRI Shapefiles

Canada FSA Postal Code Shapefile

GNIS Shapefiles 2,000,000+ Points

Nuclear Energy Facilities in the U.S.

Download Zip Code with Demographics Shapefiles

Download U.S. Streams & Rivers Shapefiles

Download Water Body & Wetland Shapefiles

Download Zip Code Boundary Shapefiles

Download School District Shapefiles

Download Indian & Federal Land Shapefiles

Download Climate Change Shapefiles

Download Tornado Shapefiles

Download Dams & Risks Shapefiles

Follow Mapcruzin.com on Twitter Follow on Twitter

A Member of the
Reimagination Network

Didn't find what you are looking for? Email me and I'll find it for you.

Progressive Links

Federation of American Scientists

Physicians for Social Responsibility

Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility

Union of Concerned Scientists

Alternet

Reader Supported News

Common Dreams

Truthout

Huffington Post

Media Matters

Think Progress

Grist Environmental News

Have a question or comment? Post them at the MapCruzin Blog.

Climate Shift Blog

MapCruzin Consulting
GIS and Google Maps Development, Website Creation and Hosting, Fast and Affordable.

GIS Tutorials

GIS Basics

GIS Terminology

Of Interest

Arctic National Wildlife Refuge Maps

Climate Shift - The effects of climate shift on the future of planet earth and its inhabitants.

Right to Know or Left to Wonder?

Hazardscapes - Toxic and Nuclear Risks in your backyard.

War & Environment

Worst Case Scenarios: Terrorism & industrial chemicals.


Subscribe for Updates


Gene-Modified Plants and Animals Could Wipe Out Other Species, Experts Fear Oversight is full of holes
Fair Use Statement

Source: Common Dreams

Published on Tuesday, January 2, 2001 in the Los Angeles Times

Gene-Modified Plants and Animals Could Wipe Out Other Species, Experts Fear Oversight is 'full of holes.'
by Aaron Zitner

AUBURN, Alabama -- A few miles outside this college town, down a gravel road that runs through rolling woodlands, Rex Dunham has turned a set of muddy ponds into a high-security prison for fish.

Electric wire keeps the raccoons at bay. Netting blocks the herons from swooping in. Filters stop the fish from slipping out with the waste water.

Federal officials asked Dunham to protect the local environment from the catfish he grows here because nothing like them has ever cut the waters of the Earth. These catfish have been laced with DNA from salmon, carp and zebrafish, which makes them grow as much as 60% faster than normal. That could help farmers feed more people for less money and boost efforts to end world hunger.

But there also is a chance that fast-growing fish might touch off an environmental disaster, according to scientists who have studied the matter. Their greatest fear is that Dunham's catfish will escape and wipe out other fish species, as well as the plants and animals that depend on those fish to survive.

And now, some scientists and government officials are raising a second and equally troubling concern: that the federal government has limited legal authority to protect the environment from Dunham's catfish--or from some of the dozens of other genetically modified plants and animals now being readied for market.

"Here we are on the brink of remaking life on Earth through genetic engineering, and we do not have a thorough process for reviewing the environmental impacts," said William Brown, science advisor to Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt. "The system is full of holes."

"My sense is that the current system is not going to be OK and that there are going to have to be changes--or a whole new system put in," said Bill Knapp, a senior fisheries official with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

This view is far from universal. But concerns about the government's legal authority are significant enough that President Clinton ordered federal agencies in May to review the relevant laws and probe for holes. The review is due to be completed early this month.

Americans already eat modified corn, potatoes and other crops. Soon to come are the first such animals: disease-resistant shrimp, meatier chickens and fast-growing salmon. Thanks to mouse DNA, a new pig produces a less harmful manure. New crops include a rice, mixed with daffodil DNA, that includes more nutrients.

Dunham, an Auburn University researcher, already has started seeking federal approvals to sell his fish. And he could be among the first to win approvals to sell a genetically modified animal to American consumers.

Although there has been great attention paid to whether these foods are safe to eat, Brown and others say the potential risk to the environment could be an even bigger concern. And, the government is stretching outdated laws to cover the gene revolution, they say, as if using 19th century railroad laws to regulate airlines.

Some warn that genetically modified plants and animals could move into the wild and breed disruptive traits into local species, similar to the way African "killer bees" escaped a Brazilian research facility in 1957 and spread their aggressive traits. Others fear an opposite scenario: that instead of thriving, the modified plant or animal could interbreed with its natural cousins in ways that would destroy the species entirely.

Scientists call this the "Trojan gene" effect, because the modified organism is undermined by the new genes that it takes in. William M. Muir, a geneticist at Purdue University, has used a mix of laboratory observation and computer modeling to show that it could happen with gene-altered fish.

Fast-growing fish might enjoy a mating advantage in the wild, Muir says, yet produce young that are ill-equipped to survive. "This could locally take a population to extinction," he said.

And yet, federal officials say that no law requires people who alter fish genes to keep the fish isolated and away from local waters. The Agriculture Department was able to ask Dunham to build his "fish prison" only because his research is backed by federal funds.

Moreover, officials said, it is unclear whether any federal law penalizes a person who releases genetically modified animals into the wild.

More troubling to some critics is that certain species may escape federal regulation entirely.

For example, at least one company is altering the genes in creeping bentgrass, a common golf course turf, so that it is more resistant to weed killers. That would allow lawn managers to use herbicides without harming the turf. But it could also make the grass, which already invades lawns and gardens, harder for homeowners to control.

Officials are divided over whether the government has the authority to regulate genetic changes to the grass. The Agriculture Department claims authority over all "plant pests" and potential pests, and it is using that authority to supervise the company working on creeping bentgrass genes. But Brown and others disagree, saying that the legal definition of plant pests clearly excludes the grass. The department has overstepped its legal authority, Brown says.

Similarly, several teams are working to modify algae as a food and laboratory substance, said Anne Kapuscinski, a fish geneticist at the University of Minnesota. Algae is not a plant pest, she said, "so who is going to have authority over it? There's been no public statement on that."

The confusion arises because the government, starting with the Reagan administration, decided that decades-old food and agriculture laws could be stretched to cover genetically altered species.

For example, some corn and potato varieties already on the market have been genetically modified to produce their own insecticide. Because the Environmental Protection Agency has jurisdiction over insecticides, it takes a lead role in regulating these crops.

For other crops, the Agriculture Department claims a leading role because scientists commonly use bacteria and viruses to modify the crop genes. The agency already regulates those bacteria and viruses as plant pests, and it claims jurisdiction over the crops as well.

Jane Rissler, senior staff scientist with the Union of Concerned Scientists, called this rationale "an awkward stretch of the laws" that does not cast a broad net over all gene-altered plants. The mere fact that genes have been engineered should be enough to bring a plant or animal under federal scrutiny, she said.

Besides, scientists now are modifying genes in ways that do not rely on bacteria or viruses but that should not release them from federal regulation, Rissler said.

In regulating fish, some people believe the laws are being stretched in equally awkward ways.

Dunham had spent years using traditional breeding techniques to modify the channel catfish, which is by far the most farmed fish in the United States.

Then, in 1982, American scientists created one of the first transgenic animals--mice that grew to twice their normal size, thanks to rat and human genes that produce growth hormone. The mouse experiment prompted other scientists to start manipulating traits in a range of species. Many researchers saw the new technology as a way to help farmers produce more food with less resources.

"If we can grow more fish in less space, that decreases pressure on the environment," Dunham said. "And we will never be able to catch more fish than we do now from the natural environment. Yet world demand for fish is increasing."

Normally, catfish stop growing in the winter, when the genes that produce growth hormone all but shut down. Dunham and his team began producing catfish that had an extra copy of a growth hormone gene. They also added a piece of DNA from salmon, carp or other species that acts like a year-round "on" switch for the gene.

The result: Dunham's catfish grow to their market size of about 2 pounds within 12 to 18 months, rather than the normal 18 to 24 months.

Dunham and his research partner, Zhanjiang "John" Liu, hope to turn the fish into a commercial product. Several fish geneticists believe the Auburn catfish could be the second genetically modified animal to reach American consumers. A/F Protein Inc., a Massachusetts firm, is expected to be first. It is seeking approval for a fast-growing salmon that it is developing in indoor tanks in Canada.

Dunham and Liu also have begun researching how their fish would behave in the wild. So far, they say, they have found no cause for concern.

One published study found that the fish have slightly less ability to avoid predators than do native catfish. Two other studies, not yet published, determined that the Auburn catfish do not have a competitive edge over native fish for food and have equal reproductive ability.

"What it points to is that these fish have no environmental advantage, or maybe are a little handicapped in the natural environment," Dunham said. "But the principal point is that we need more research to determine what the environmental risk is."

If Dunham and Liu commercialize the catfish, the lead regulator would be the Food and Drug Administration--but not because the fish would be a food. Instead, the agency considers the fish's extra growth hormone to be a drug.

But some wildlife experts say that, although the FDA is well-equipped to assess drugs, it is the wrong agency to rule on whether genetically modified fish pose a risk to the environment. "People understand intuitively that this is asking a lot of the FDA, asking it to become a wildlife regulatory agency," Brown said.

FDA officials say they are routinely called on to consider environmental effects. John Matheson, senior review scientist for veterinary medicine, noted that, when the agency recently reviewed a growth hormone for cows, it studied potential changes in land-use patterns, soil erosion and methane levels.

Critics of the system raise another complaint about the FDA's role: It operates under a federal law that aggressively protects company trade secrets, and an often anxious public cannot learn what genetically modified plants and animals are on the road to winning federal approvals.

"If there was a chance to look at the process and contribute to the decision-making, it would be a lot easier to win over the trust of the public," Kapuscinski said. "You'd still have some criticism, but you'd have more trust."

Didn't find what you are looking for? We've been online since 1996 and have created 1000's of pages. Search below and you may find just what you are looking for.



MapCruzin.com is an independent firm specializing in the publication of educational and research resources. We created the first U.S. based interactive toxic chemical facility maps on the internet in 1996 and we have been online ever since. Learn more about us and view some of our projects and services.

If you have data, GIS project or custom shapefile needs send me an email.

Contact Us

Report Broken Links

Subscribe for Updates

Advertise on MapCruzin

Follow on Facebook
News & Updates

Find: Maps, Shapefiles, GIS Software & More

MapCruzin Blog for updates, questions and answers

Mapcruzin Free GIS Tools, Resources, News and Maps

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Blog Updates

More Blog Updates

Downloads

Google Earth Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) Maps
Lester Brown's Plan B 3.0
State GIS Shapefiles, Maps & Resources
GIS Shapefiles & Maps
GIS Programs, Tools & Resources
Free World Country & Regional Maps
GIS / GPS Careers and Job Positions
Disease Outbreak Maps
TOPO Maps
Extreme Weather & Disaster Maps
Free World Maps from the CIA Factbook
Arctic National Wildlife Refuge ANWR Maps
Oil and Gas Maps
Africanized Honey Bees
Renewable Energy Potential Maps of the United States
Terrorism Maps
War Maps
Google Maps
Weather Maps
GPS Resources
Historical Maps of the World
Google Earth
Library of Congress American Memory Map Downloads
Toxic Chemical Pollution Maps
Climate Change Maps
Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) Maps
Census Shapefiles
World Maps

Issues

Environmental Justice
Data Sources
Greenwash & JunkScience
Statistical Resources
Wireless Dangers
Surviving Climate Change
Global Right-To-Know
Creating Living Economies
Books of Note
Toxic Klamath River
Federal Lands Maps
TRI Analysis
TRI Webmaps
EnviroRisk Map Network
Community-Based Research
Right-To-Know or Left to Wonder?
Chemical Industry Archives
21st Century Warfare
Biotechnology
Nanotechnology
Globalization/Democracy
National Parks and Public Lands
Trade Secrets/Toxic Deception
GIS Books
Our Projects
Other Projects
1999 Archive Environews
Environmental Books
Environmental Links
Redwood Coast Information
Recycle, Salvage, Reuse

Resources
Shapefile Store
Free GIS Software
Free Map Downloads
Free Shapefiles
Free Remote Sensing
Free Topo Maps
Free GIS Tutorial
Free GPS
ToxicRisk.com
ClimateShift.com
Maptivist.com

About MapCruzin - Cookies, Privacy, Fair Use and Disclaimer - Advertise on MapCruzin.com

Website development and hosting provided by Michael Meuser

Copyright © 1996 - 2017 Michael Meuser, All Rights Reserved
MapCruzin is a Pop-Up Free Website -- Best Viewed With ANY Browser